A new study finds that race itself is not a prognostic factor of overall survival among black patients with lung cancer. The study’s findings were presented at the third American Association for Cancer Research Conference on The Science of Cancer Health Disparities.
“In simple terms, if 100 patients who are Caucasian and 100 patients who are African-American have the same age, stage of cancer, type of lung cancer, and are treated the same way, there should not be differences in their survival just because they are different races,” said Rajesh Sehgal, MD, medical oncologist at the Edwards Comprehensive Cancer Center and assistant professor of medicine at the Marshall University Joan C. Edwards School of Medicine in Huntington, WVa.
“African-American patients did have lesser medial overall survival, but after compensating for all other factors that affect prognosis, such as age, stage and type of treatment, African-American race was not an independent prognostic factor of poor survival,” added Sehgal.
Results of the study also indicated that those patients of other races—including Asian and Hispanic patients—had a better disease prognosis when compared with African-American and Caucasian patients, indicating that there may be biological differences in the tumors in these races.
The researchers used data from the Cancer Information Resource File to examine 130,517 patients diagnosed with lung cancer between 2003 and 2008. Patients were grouped according to race: white (91.4%), African-American (6.5%), and other (2.1%), defined as any non-Caucasian and non-African-American patients.
Median overall survival was 10.3 months for Caucasian patients, 9.1 months for African-American patients, and 11.8 months for patients of other races. Patients undergoing chemotherapy had about 43% higher chance of survival and those undergoing surgery had about 60% higher chance of survival.
Data indicated that fewer African-American patients underwent surgery to treat their disease and a greater percentage of these patients presented with metastatic lung cancer compared with Caucasian patients (44% versus 41%). These factors may have contributed to less favorable medial overall survival compared with Caucasian patients and patients of other races, according to the researchers.
Despite these differences, race alone did not affect overall survival. However, race was an independent risk factor for patients of other races compared with Caucasian patients.
“If possible, we would like to look into the tumor biology of ‘other’ races to see when differences exist in their tumors as compared to Caucasian and African-American patients and whether these differences might account for their better prognosis,” said Sehgal.
Other factors identified by researchers as having a negative effect on overall survival were age older than 70 years and male sex. When they presented with the disease, 67% of all African-American patients were younger than 70 years of age, while only 54% of Caucasian patients were.
Patients undergoing radiation therapy and patients with bronchoalveolar lung cancer histology also had improved prognosis.
According to the researchers, the study did have some limitations, including a lack of data on patients’ smoking status, insurance status, and comorbidities, all of which could affect overall survival.
Source: American Association for Cancer Research
